Library · Theology

The Treatise on the Eucharist

Summa Theologica, Part III, Questions 73–83

Who it’s for

Readers who want the classic theological reasoning behind the Real Presence and are willing to work through dense, precise argument.

St. Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274), the Dominican friar and Doctor of the Church, wrote the Summa Theologica as an orderly course in theology. The Third Part, on Christ and the sacraments, was the last part Thomas worked on, and he left it unfinished. Questions 73 to 83 are his treatise on the Eucharist, and they have deeply shaped how the Church explains the Real Presence. Tradition also credits him with the hymns for the feast of Corpus Christi.

How it is organized. Each question is divided into articles. Every article follows the same pattern: a yes-or-no question, objections against Thomas’s view, an authority “On the contrary,” his own answer (“I answer that”), and a reply to each objection. This volume, the “Third Number” of Part III, also contains the questions on the sacraments in general, Baptism, and Confirmation. The Eucharist begins with Question 73 on page 232.

Where to start. Read Question 73 (page 232) on what the sacrament is, its names, its institution, and its figures in the Old Testament. Then the heart of the treatise: Question 75 (page 262), on the change of bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ; Question 76 (page 285), on the way in which Christ is in the sacrament; and Question 77 (page 305), on the “accidents,” the appearances of bread and wine, that remain. Question 79 (page 349) treats the effects of Holy Communion. Question 80 (page 367) treats receiving it, including the difference between eating it sacramentally and spiritually (Article 1) and whether to receive daily (Article 10). Question 83 (page 433), on the rite of the Mass, closes the volume.

What to know. The Dominican translators rendered Thomas literally, and he uses the terms of Aristotle’s philosophy, such as substance, accidents, and species, which take some getting used to. Scripture is quoted from the Latin Vulgate. The last article of Question 83 quotes medieval penances for accidents with the Sacred Species, which reflect the discipline of that age. This 1923 printing reissues the translation first published in 1914. The EPUB is Project Gutenberg’s text of the same Dominican translation; a spot check against this scan found the wording the same. It contains all of Part III, so use its table of contents to go to Question 73.