Eucharistic miracle · 2013–2016

Legnica, Poland

A Host dropped at Christmas Mass in 2013 and placed in water developed a red spot. After two laboratories reached different results, the bishop announced in 2016, having consulted Rome, that the event had the hallmarks of a Eucharistic miracle.

What happened

On Christmas Day 2013, during Communion at St. Hyacinth’s Church in Legnica, a city in southwestern Poland, a consecrated Host fell to the floor. It was picked up and placed in a vessel of water to dissolve, as the Church’s rules provide. According to the parish priest, Fr. Andrzej Ziombra, the priest giving Communion that day was unwell and had little feeling in his fingers.

On January 4, 2014, one of the parish priests noticed that about a fifth of the Host had turned red. Bishop Stefan Cichy of Legnica told them to wait another two weeks. When the red fragment was still floating, he set up a commission to study it. In February 2014 the red fragment was separated and laid on a corporal.

What was examined

The commission first turned to the Department of Forensic Medicine at Wrocław Medical University, which took 15 samples. Besides fragments of the Host, these included the liquid from the vessel, the Mass wine, and the tap water used. According to Dr. Barbara Engel, a cardiologist on the commission, the Wrocław histology showed fibrous structures that most resembled heart muscle, but the material was very hard to study. A stain for fungi colored the fungal threads around the fibers but not the fibers themselves. No DNA was found. Fr. Tadeusz Dąbski, the diocese’s judicial vicar, later said the Wrocław opinion twice stated that the images did not allow firm conclusions. That answer did not satisfy the commission, he said, so it kept asking.

In mid-2015 the material already prepared for study was sent to the Department of Forensic Medicine at the Pomeranian Medical University in Szczecin. Its opinion, quoted in the bishop’s announcement, described fragments of striated muscle and called the overall picture “most similar to the heart muscle,” with changes that often accompany agony. Engel said Szczecin used a more sensitive DNA method that showed human genetic material. Dąbski said the scientists directing the work knew where the material came from, but those carrying out the tests did not.

What the Church has said

In January 2016, Bishop Zbigniew Kiernikowski, Cichy’s successor, presented the case to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in Rome. In April 2016 he announced that the event “has the hallmarks of a Eucharistic miracle.” Following the Holy See’s recommendations, he asked the parish to prepare a fitting place where the relic could be venerated, to give regular teaching on Eucharistic devotion, and to keep a book recording graces received. Polish sources date the announcement to April 10 or 11, 2016. Catholic News Agency reported it as April 17.

The wording matters. Church officials in Legnica have consistently spoken of an event with the hallmarks of a miracle, not a declared miracle. In 2018 Fr. Ziombra told the diocesan weekly that recognizing a miracle is reserved to the Holy See. In 2020, Catholic News Agency reported that the Vatican continued to follow the case. Ziombra said that records of conversions and healings would be sent to Rome to inform a final statement. He also said that more research was needed to tell whose DNA had been found.

We have found no further Vatican statement, including any under the 2024 norms.

Questions that remain

Two laboratories, one sample. The positive result came from a second laboratory examining material the first had found inconclusive, after the commission was dissatisfied with the first answer. The head of the Szczecin department, Prof. Mirosław Parafiniuk, told Gazeta Wyborcza that the sample reached his laboratory as a paraffin block. Samples in that form pass through many hands and are easily contaminated, including with human DNA. He added that such material would be of little value in a criminal case.

The first laboratory’s view. Prof. Tadeusz Dobosz, whose molecular laboratory in Wrocław did the first tests, publicly questioned the miracle claim in a 2016 video interview. In 2025 he and colleagues, including a Wrocław priest-theologian, published a study of 25 other cases of discolored Hosts from Poland, Germany, the United States, and South Africa. None showed real evidence of human blood, and the authors concluded that the Hosts’ appearance could be explained by contamination, identifying bacteria and molds such as Serratia marcescens, Epicoccum, and Fusarium. The authors also criticized the release of partial results in popular books rather than scientific journals, citing a 2017 book about Legnica.

Identification by eye. Kelly Kearse and Frank Ligaj note in a 2024 review that, by the investigators’ own account, the tissue was too degraded for immunohistochemical confirmation. The heart-muscle reading therefore rests on how the tissue looked. They also doubt that the DNA was compared with that of everyone who had handled the sample.

What believers point to. The commission sampled the water, the wine, and other Hosts for comparison, and a second forensic department reached a firmer conclusion. The bishop consulted Rome before speaking. The parish also reports many conversions and a steady stream of pilgrims from around the world.

Visiting today

The relic is displayed in a reliquary in a side aisle of St. Hyacinth’s, which the diocesan press now calls a shrine. In 2018 the diocesan weekly reported that more than 700 organized pilgrim groups had come, that visitors fill books with prayers and thanks, and that adoration of the Blessed Sacrament continues in a side chapel throughout the week.

Sources and further reading

This account is written in our own words from the sources above. If you know of a correction or a better source, please tell us.