I'm a Christian, but not Catholic · Part 1

John 6: “My flesh is food indeed”

In the synagogue at Capernaum, Jesus called Himself the bread of life, and then said something so hard that many of His disciples walked away. What did He mean?

John is the only Gospel that doesn’t tell the story of the Last Supper’s bread and cup. Instead, a year earlier in Jesus’ ministry, it gives us a long sermon about bread. Christians often call it the Bread of Life discourse, and it is the best place to begin.

Passover, loaves, and manna

John notes the season: “Now the Passover, the feast of the Jews, was at hand” (John 6:4). Jesus feeds five thousand people with five barley loaves. The next day the crowd finds Him in Capernaum and asks for another sign, reminding Him that “Our fathers ate the manna in the wilderness” (v. 31).

Jesus answers that the true bread from heaven is not manna but something the Father gives now:

I am the bread of life. Whoever comes to me will not be hungry, and whoever believes in me will never be thirsty.

John 6:35

All Christians agree about this much. In verses 35–47 the emphasis is on coming to Jesus and believing in Him. Catholics affirm that wholeheartedly: no one receives Christ fruitfully without faith.

The turn at verse 51

Then the language changes. Jesus begins to speak of His flesh as something to be given and eaten:

“I am the living bread which came down out of heaven. If anyone eats of this bread, he will live forever. Yes, the bread which I will give for the life of the world is my flesh.” The Jews therefore contended with one another, saying, “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?” Jesus therefore said to them, “Most certainly I tell you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you don’t have life in yourselves. He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day. For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed. He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood lives in me, and I in him. As the living Father sent me, and I live because of the Father, so he who feeds on me will also live because of me. This is the bread which came down out of heaven—not as our fathers ate the manna and died. He who eats this bread will live forever.”

John 6:51–58

Notice three things.

First, the gift is future and sacrificial: “the bread which I will give for the life of the world is my flesh.” This looks ahead to the cross. Catholics believe it also looks ahead to the meal in which the fruit of the cross is given.

Second, the crowd took Him literally, and they were scandalized. The Greek verb in verse 52 suggests a fierce quarrel.

Third, Jesus does not soften what He said. He makes it stronger. He adds the drinking of His blood, something no devout Jew could hear without a shudder (Leviticus 17:10–14). He says His flesh is “food indeed.” The Greek word is alēthēs, which many translations render “true food.”

A change of verb

Up to verse 53, John uses the ordinary Greek verb for eating. From verse 54 on, he switches to trōgō, a word that in older Greek meant to gnaw, munch, or chew. Many Catholic commentators, and some Protestant ones, see this as Jesus pressing the point: this is real eating, not a figure of speech for believing.

To be fair, this is debated. By New Testament times trōgō may simply have become a common way of saying “eat,” and John uses it in 13:18 for ordinary eating: “He who eats bread with me.” The change of verb proves nothing on its own. But it fits a larger pattern in the passage. As the objections grow, Jesus’ words become more concrete, not less.

When Jesus is misunderstood

Elsewhere in the Gospels, when people take a figure of speech literally, Jesus corrects them. When He said Lazarus had “fallen asleep” and the disciples misunderstood, “Jesus said to them plainly then, ‘Lazarus is dead’” (John 11:14). When He warned against “the yeast of the Pharisees” and they thought He meant bread, He explained Himself (Matthew 16:6–12).

In John 6 He offers no such correction. Instead:

Therefore many of his disciples, when they heard this, said, “This is a hard saying! Who can listen to it?” … At this, many of his disciples went back and walked no more with him.

John 6:60, 66

These were disciples, and Jesus let them go. Then He turned to the Twelve: “You don’t also want to go away, do you?” (v. 67). Peter answered:

Lord, to whom would we go? You have the words of eternal life. We have come to believe and know that you are the Christ, the Son of the living God.

John 6:68–69

Peter doesn’t claim to understand. He trusts the One who said it.

“The flesh profits nothing”

Between the grumbling and the leaving comes the verse most often cited against a literal reading:

It is the spirit who gives life. The flesh profits nothing. The words that I speak to you are spirit, and are life.

John 6:63

The symbolic reading. Many Protestant Christians see verse 63 as the key to the whole discourse. On this view, Jesus is telling His hearers they took Him too literally. His words are “spirit,” to be understood spiritually: to eat His flesh is to believe in Him, as verses 35 and 47 said. It is a serious reading, held by people who love Scripture.

The Catholic reading. Catholics notice that Jesus says “the flesh,” not “my flesh.” He has just said that His flesh is given “for the life of the world” (v. 51), so it can hardly profit nothing. In John’s Gospel, “flesh” set against “spirit” usually means human nature left to itself (John 3:6), as when Jesus says, “You judge according to the flesh” (John 8:15). On this reading, Jesus is saying that natural reasoning cannot grasp His words; only the faith the Father gives can (vv. 64–65). And in the Bible, “spirit” doesn’t mean “symbolic.”

Notice, too, what happens after verse 63: the disciples still leave (v. 66). If Jesus had just explained that He was speaking only in metaphor, why would that be the moment they walked away?

St. Augustine (354–430) said the departing disciples imagined Jesus would cut off pieces of His body and hand them out (Exposition on Psalm 99, 8). That crude reading is what Jesus rejected, and Catholics reject it too. But we believe we truly receive Him.

Reading it for yourself

John 6 alone doesn’t settle the question, and faithful Christians read it differently. But it is worth asking honestly: if Jesus meant only “believe in me,” why did He let so many disciples leave over a misunderstanding He could have cleared up in a sentence?

In the next chapter we go to the Upper Room, where Jesus took bread into His hands and said, “This is my body.”

Going further

Scripture quotations are from the World English Bible (public domain) unless otherwise noted. References marked “CCC” are to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

Other starting points

Something on your mind that this doesn’t answer? Ask us privately.