Ask a thoughtful Catholic why they believe the Host is Christ, and they won’t point to the Host. They’ll point to Jesus.
The Catechism says plainly that Christ’s presence in the sacrament “cannot be apprehended by the senses,” but only “by faith, which relies on divine authority” (CCC 1381). So the reasoning runs like this:
- If Jesus is who he claimed to be, his word can be trusted.
- He said of the bread, “this is my body” (Matthew 26:26), and taught, “my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed” (John 6:55).
- So the bread, after his word, is his body.
Everything hangs on the first step. For a skeptic, the question of the Eucharist turns out to be the question of Jesus.
The first listeners found it hard too
The first audience found this no easier than you might. After Jesus spoke about eating his flesh, his own disciples said: “This is a hard saying! Who can listen to it?” (John 6:60). Then: “At this, many of his disciples went back and walked no more with him” (John 6:66).
Jesus turned to the twelve and asked whether they wanted to leave too. Peter’s answer is the Catholic position in miniature:
Lord, to whom would we go? You have the words of eternal life. We have come to believe and know that you are the Christ, the Son of the living God.
John 6:68–69
Peter doesn’t say he understands. He says he trusts the one speaking. (Other Christians read John 6 differently, and the Christian pathway sets out those readings fairly.)
Who was Jesus?
He existed. Very few historians, religious or not, doubt that Jesus of Nazareth was a real Jewish teacher who was crucified under Pontius Pilate. Besides the Gospels and the letters of Paul, he is mentioned by the Jewish historian Josephus (around AD 93) and the Roman historian Tacitus (around AD 116), neither of them a Christian.
His followers said he rose from the dead, and said it early. Writing to the church in Corinth around AD 55, Paul passed on a summary that he says he had himself received:
For I delivered to you first of all that which I also received: that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. Then he appeared to over five hundred brothers at once, most of whom remain until now…
1 Corinthians 15:3–6
Many historians, including some who don’t believe in the resurrection, think this formula goes back to within a few years of the crucifixion. Paul is saying, in effect: the witnesses are still alive; go and ask them.
They had little to gain. The first Christians faced ridicule, exclusion, and sometimes death. Ignatius of Antioch, quoted below, wrote his letters under armed guard on his way to execution in Rome.
People die for false beliefs all the time, so martyrdom proves sincerity, not truth. The point is narrower: the earliest witnesses were in a position to know whether they had actually seen Jesus alive again, and under pressure they didn’t recant.
Skeptical historians offer other explanations, such as visions brought on by grief or legends that grew in the retelling, and those deserve a fair hearing. Our claim is only that the resurrection is a serious historical question, not a fairy tale. If it happened, Jesus’ words about the bread deserve to be taken at face value.
Not a medieval invention
People sometimes assume the Real Presence was dreamed up in the Middle Ages. The word transubstantiation does come from then; it was used by the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215. But the belief it names is much older.
Around AD 107, Ignatius, bishop of Antioch, warned the church in Smyrna about a breakaway group:
They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins, and which the Father, of His goodness, raised up again.
Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Smyrnaeans, 7 (trans. Roberts and Donaldson, 1885)
Around 155, the philosopher Justin Martyr explained Christian worship to the Roman emperor:
For not as common bread and common drink do we receive these; but in like manner as Jesus Christ our Saviour, having been made flesh by the Word of God, had both flesh and blood for our salvation, so likewise have we been taught that the food which is blessed by the prayer of His word, and from which our blood and flesh by transmutation are nourished, is the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh.
Justin Martyr, First Apology, 66 (trans. Dods and Reith, 1885)
Outsiders noticed, and drew the worst conclusion. Around 177, the Christian writer Athenagoras listed the rumors circulating about his community: “Three things are alleged against us: atheism, Thyestean feasts, Œdipodean intercourse” (A Plea for the Christians, 3). A “Thyestean feast,” from a Greek myth, was a meal of human flesh. (Christians were called atheists because they refused to worship the gods.) Around 112, the Roman governor Pliny the Younger, after interrogating Christians, reported to the emperor Trajan that their shared meal was ordinary, harmless food. That he bothered to say so suggests he had heard otherwise.
Rumors of cannibalism don’t usually attach to people who speak only of symbols.
A cumulative case, and still a choice
None of this is a proof. It is a cumulative case: a historical Jesus; an early and stubborn testimony that he rose; and a community that, from its first generations, took his words about the bread at face value and was mocked for it. Each strand can be questioned. Together, many intelligent people have found them strong enough to bear the weight of trust.
But trust is what it finally comes down to. At some point the evidence runs out, and a person has to decide whether to believe someone. Catholics call that faith, and would point out that it’s how we come to know most of the people we love.
If you’re not there, that’s an honest place to be. You’re welcome to keep looking.
Going further
- Eucharistic miracles: what was claimed, and what was found
- I’m a Christian, but not Catholic: John 6, the Last Supper, and the early writers in more depth
- The library: Ignatius and Justin in full
Scripture quotations are from the World English Bible (public domain) unless otherwise noted. References marked “CCC” are to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.