Eucharistic miracle · 1263 (by tradition)

Bolsena–Orvieto, Italy

Tradition says a doubting priest saw the Host bleed at Mass in Bolsena in 1263, and that the bloodstained corporal moved Pope Urban IV to extend the feast of Corpus Christi to the whole Church. The corporal is venerated in Orvieto, but the miracle first appears in the record some 70 years later, and historians debate its link to the feast.

What happened

According to the tradition kept at Bolsena and Orvieto, in 1263 a priest from Bohemia, whom later accounts call Peter of Prague, was traveling home from a pilgrimage to Rome. (Some versions call him German, and some give the year as 1264.) He had been troubled by doubts about the Real Presence. Stopping at Bolsena, a town on a lake north of Rome, he said Mass in the church of St. Christina. At the consecration, the story says, the Host began to bleed. The blood stained the corporal, the square of linen on which the Host and chalice rest, and dripped onto the marble floor.

Pope Urban IV was then staying in nearby Orvieto. Told what had happened, he is said to have sent the bishop of Orvieto to fetch the corporal and to have gone out to meet it. The corporal has been kept in Orvieto ever since. In 1264, Urban extended the feast of Corpus Christi to the whole Church with the bull Transiturus, and tradition says the miracle moved him to do so.

What the records show

The feast and the miracle have separate histories. The feast of Corpus Christi grew out of the devotion of St. Juliana of Mont Cornillon, near Liège in present-day Belgium, and in 1246 the bishop of Liège ordered it kept in his diocese. One of those who heard Juliana’s ideas was Jacques Pantaléon, then archdeacon of Liège, who became Pope Urban IV in 1261. Transiturus explains the Pope’s reasons for the feast without mentioning Bolsena. Urban died in October 1264, and the feast spread slowly until Clement V renewed it at the Council of Vienne in 1311–12. The texts for its Mass and Office are traditionally credited to St. Thomas Aquinas, who was teaching at Orvieto at the time.

The miracle appears in the record later. The oldest surviving depiction is a set of enamel scenes on the great silver reliquary made for the corporal by the Sienese goldsmith Ugolino di Vieri in 1337–38. An inscription telling the story at Bolsena dates from after Aquinas’s canonization in 1323. In 1344, Pope Clement VI referred to the relic’s origin only vaguely, as some miracle, and Pope Gregory XI gave a short account of it in a brief in the 1370s. Contemporary biographers of Urban IV, including one who described his stay at Orvieto in detail and mentioned the new feast, say nothing of a miracle. The 1911 Catholic Encyclopedia, published with the Church’s approval, put it bluntly:

The Miracle of Bolsena is not supported by strong historical evidence, and its tradition is not altogether consistent.

Catholic Encyclopedia, “Orvieto” (1911)

It also noted that St. Antoninus of Florence, in the 15th century, mentioned only drops from the chalice falling on the corporal, not a doubting priest.

In 2015 the corporal underwent conservation. According to the local press, the conservator reported, on the basis of ultraviolet photography, deposits she described as blood separated into plasma and serum. No laboratory or DNA analysis was reported.

What the Church has said

Popes have honored the relic for centuries. Julius II prayed before it in 1506, and Raphael painted The Mass at Bolsena for him in the Vatican Palace around 1512. Paul VI came to Orvieto on August 11, 1964, for the 700th anniversary of Transiturus. Preaching there in 1990, John Paul II spoke of the corporal as a miraculous sign, while noting that the building of the cathedral was not directly connected either to the feast or to the miracle. We know of no formal decree declaring the miracle authentic.

Questions that remain

How closely are the miracle and the feast linked? On the documents, the feast came from Liège, and the earliest record of the miracle comes some 70 years after it. Historians who rely on the documents therefore treat the link as a later tradition. Catholic sources, including Vatican News, still describe the miracle as the origin of the feast. Both may be partly right, since a pope who already favored the feast could have been encouraged by an event he left out of a formal bull. The record cannot settle it.

What happened at the altar? Since the 19th century, scientists have known that a red-pigmented bacterium, now called Serratia marcescens, can grow on damp bread and look like blood (see our chapter on Eucharistic miracles). Writers on the bacterium’s history have often pointed to Bolsena as a possible example. That remains a hypothesis: as far as we can find, the stains have never been tested for it. A believer will note that the tradition places the bleeding at the very moment of consecration, which slow contamination does not easily explain. A skeptic will answer that this detail comes from much later accounts.

Visiting today

The corporal is kept in the Chapel of the Corporal in Orvieto Cathedral and is carried through the city in procession on the feast of Corpus Christi. In Bolsena, the Basilica of St. Christina preserves the altar where the miracle is said to have happened and marble stones said to bear the stains.

Sources and further reading

This account is written in our own words from the sources above. If you know of a correction or a better source, please tell us.