What happened
The story, as it is told in Santarém, concerns a woman whose husband had turned away from her. Hoping to win him back, she went to a woman who promised a remedy, at the price of a consecrated Host. She then received Communion in her parish of St. Stephen, but instead of swallowing the Host she kept it in her mouth, then took it out and wrapped it in a cloth. As she went through the streets, people saw blood dripping from the cloth and asked if she was hurt. Frightened, she went home and hid the Host in a chest.
That night, the story continues, light streamed from the chest and woke her and her husband. She told him everything, and they spent the rest of the night in prayer. In the morning the priest was called, and the Host was carried back to the church in procession. A later episode tells how the Host, long kept in a wax container, was one day found inside a small crystal vessel instead. The Host, with what is described as dried blood, is still kept at the church, now the Sanctuary of the Most Holy Miracle.
What the records show
No 13th-century document describing the event is known. The fullest early account is a Latin text first printed in 1612 by the Portuguese scholar Pedro de Mariz, who said he copied it from an old parchment book in the archive of St. Stephen’s church. In a 2020 study, the philologist Manuel Negri suggests that this manuscript may date from the 14th century, under King Afonso IV, when, according to Mariz, the miracle’s procession was formally established. Neither that book nor a second old manuscript survives; the last was consulted in 1897. Negri searched part of the church’s old archive, now in Portugal’s national archive at the Torre do Tombo, in 2019 without finding either.
The year is uncertain. Mariz’s text gives 1266 and places the event in the reign of King Afonso III. In 1740 the historian Inácio da Piedade e Vasconcelos argued for 1247, citing the other old book. Negri thinks 1247 more likely, partly because the Roman numerals for the two years are easy to confuse in copying, but he grants that no further evidence settles the question. Popular accounts give still other years.
Negri also argues that one of the Cantigas de Santa Maria, the songs compiled at the court of King Alfonso X of Castile in the second half of the 13th century, borrowed from the Santarém story. If he is right, the story was known at a royal court within a few decades. That argument rests on literary resemblance, though, not on a document that names Santarém.
As far as we can find, the relic itself has never been scientifically examined.
What the Church has said
The Host has been venerated in Santarém for centuries, and the parish church of St. Stephen came to be known by the miracle’s name. Some devotional sources list papal indulgences granted to its pilgrims over the centuries; we have not been able to check those documents. We have found no modern formal Church judgment on the event. Catholics are free to accept it or not.
Questions that remain
The late text. Our account was printed more than three centuries after the event, from a lost manuscript that was itself probably written decades after it.
A familiar plot. Negri traces close parallels in earlier stories. St. Peter Damian, writing in the 11th century, told of a jealous wife who kept a Host to use in a charm. A similar case from Alatri, in Italy, was reported to Pope Gregory IX in the 13th century, and the German monk Caesarius of Heisterbach told another. The resemblance does not prove the Santarém story false, but it shows how such stories traveled and took on a common shape.
A harmful detail. In the Latin text Mariz printed, the woman who demands the Host is described as Jewish. Many medieval Host stories cast Jews in this role, and accusations modeled on such stories led to the killing of Jews in many places. Modern retellings usually call her a sorceress. The Church has since condemned hatred of Jews and antisemitism at any time and by anyone (Nostra Aetate 4).
Later wonders. The old text reports further signs seen in the Host by later visitors, such as figures appearing in it, and devotional accounts add claims of fresh bleeding over the centuries. We found no independent documentation of any of these.
A believer can reasonably say that a lost manuscript is not a disproof, and that a devotion kept alive in one parish for some seven centuries is itself a kind of testimony. A historian can only add that the details can no longer be checked.
Visiting today
The Host is kept at the Sanctuary of the Most Holy Miracle, the former parish church of St. Stephen, in the historic center of Santarém, northeast of Lisbon. A small chapel built in the 1650s marks the site traditionally identified as the couple’s house. Check hours with the sanctuary before you go.
Sources and further reading
- Un milagre eucarístico entre Galicia e Portugal: fontes e contextos da Cantiga de Santa Maria 104 — Manuel Negri, Madrygal: Revista de Estudios Gallegos 23 (2020), pp. 255–273 (Galician, with English abstract). A scholarly study of the Santarém text, its manuscripts, its dating, and earlier stories with the same plot.
- Eucharistic miracle of Santarém — Wikipedia. Retells the tradition as it is usually told today. Its sourcing is thin.
- Host, Desecration of — Joseph Jacobs and Max Schloessinger, Jewish Encyclopedia (1906). Background on medieval accusations against Jews involving the Host, and the violence that followed them.
This account is written in our own words from the sources above. If you know of a correction or a better source, please tell us.