What happened
Santa María is a parish church on the line between the Almagro and Caballito neighborhoods of Buenos Aires. Parishioners speak of three episodes there. In May 1992, fragments of a consecrated Host left in water to dissolve were reported to have turned red. In July 1994, a minister of Holy Communion reported what looked like a drop of blood on a vessel of consecrated Hosts.
The best-known episode came in mid-August 1996. After Mass, a parishioner told Fr. Alejandro Pezet that a Host had been left in a candleholder. Because it was dirty, he did not consume it but placed it in water in the tabernacle to dissolve, the ordinary practice. When the tabernacle was opened about ten days later, the Host showed dark red patches and looked as if it were turning into flesh. Accounts differ by a few days on the dates. One 2026 newspaper account also mentions some mold around the reddened Host.
Jorge Mario Bergoglio, then an auxiliary bishop of Buenos Aires and later Pope Francis, had the Host photographed. The event was not publicized, and the Host stayed in water for about three years.
What was examined
In 1999, with the backing of Bergoglio, by then archbishop, an investigation began under Ricardo Castañón Gómez, a Bolivian clinical psychologist, working with the Australian lawyer and filmmaker Ron Tesoriero. In October 1999 a sample went to a forensic DNA laboratory in San Francisco. By the investigators’ own accounts, it recovered only a very low concentration of human DNA, along with good-quality DNA of non-human origin, and could not produce a human genetic profile.
Over the next few years, pathologists in the United States, Italy, and Australia were shown slides. According to the investigators, they described muscle or heart tissue containing white blood cells. The best-known opinion came in 2004 from Dr. Frederick Zugibe, a forensic pathologist and longtime chief medical examiner of Rockland County, New York. He described inflamed muscle from the heart’s left ventricle, infiltrated by white blood cells, and compared the injury to what he had seen in people severely beaten about the chest. Tesoriero says the examination was blind, and he quotes Zugibe’s written report of March 2005: “Prior to rendering my opinion I was not informed of the history of the material.”
Tesoriero also reports that in 2016 an Italian company, Menarini Silicon Biosystems, isolated single white blood cells from a 2005 sample. In his account, it again could not obtain a nuclear DNA profile but did recover mitochondrial DNA data, which he hopes to compare one day with blood on the Shroud of Turin. As far as we can find, these results appear only in his 2021 book, not in a scientific journal.
What the Church has said
As far as we can find, the Archdiocese of Buenos Aires has never declared any of these events a miracle; local usage prefers to speak of a Eucharistic sign. According to Tesoriero, Bergoglio agreed in 2006 that the findings could be discussed publicly.
In May 2024, Archbishop Jorge García Cuerva issued a decree to protect the Eucharistic sign at Santa María. It asks anyone holding fragments of the consecrated Hosts to return them to the parish, limits their veneration to that parish, forbids taking them elsewhere without the archbishop’s express permission, and names the pastor as their custodian, answerable to the vicar general. The decree regulates devotion. It does not rule on whether a miracle took place.
We have found no sign that the case has been taken up under the Vatican’s 2024 norms.
Questions that remain
Time and handling. The 1996 Host sat in water for about three years before testing, and samples then passed through several laboratories and many hands. The 2024 decree shows that fragments had even ended up with private individuals. Tiempo Argentino linked it to embellished retellings and to samples degraded by repeated testing.
Where the results appear. The findings are known almost entirely through the investigators’ books, films, and talks, and through Catholic media. None has been published in a peer-reviewed scientific journal.
Method. In a 2024 forensic journal article, the Catholic immunologist Kelly Kearse and his colleague Frank Ligaj argue that the investigators consulted mostly heart specialists, which presumed the answer, and that a truly blind test would have mixed the sample in with control slides prepared the same way. Tesoriero rejects their suggestion that Zugibe could have sensed the sample was unusual.
DNA. Kearse and Ligaj, and the Catholic writer Stacy Trasancos in Crisis Magazine, point out that a very low concentration of human DNA is what one would expect from people touching a sample, and that non-human DNA could come from wheat, bacteria, or molds. The popular claim that the relic holds human DNA that science cannot read goes beyond what the laboratory reported. Tesoriero agrees that the early human DNA result may reflect handling.
A believer can fairly note that several pathologists, working separately, described similar tissue. A skeptic can fairly note that all of them examined material supplied by the same small team.
Visiting today
The relics remain at Santa María, the only place they may now be venerated. Adoration takes place in a chapel of the church, and parish volunteers retell the story for visitors twice a month. The parish also keeps a relic of St. Carlo Acutis, who featured this case in his exhibition on Eucharistic miracles.
Sources and further reading
- Arzobispo dispone medidas para proteger el milagro eucarístico de Buenos Aires — ACI Prensa, May 13, 2024 (Spanish). Summarizes Archbishop García Cuerva's decree on the relic.
- Santa María, la parroquia donde los milagros son hostias con sangre y también un plato de comida — Tiempo Argentino, November 8, 2026 (Spanish). The parish today and the background to the 2024 decree.
- Three Eucharistic Miracles: Which Cases Have Undergone the Most Extensive Scientific Analysis? — National Catholic Register, June 11, 2023. A sympathetic timeline of the investigation.
- Exaggerations and Eucharistic Miracles but not in Buenos Aires 1996 — Ron Tesoriero, one of the investigators, answering critics. Describes the Zugibe examination and later DNA work.
- Scientific Analysis of Eucharistic Miracles: Importance of a Standardization in Evaluation — Kelly Kearse and Frank Ligaj, Journal of Forensic Science and Research, 2024. A critical review of the methods used.
This account is written in our own words from the sources above. If you know of a correction or a better source, please tell us.