Eucharistic miracle · 2006 (bishop's letter 2013)

Tixtla, Mexico

During a parish retreat Mass in 2006, a religious sister reported a reddish substance flowing from a consecrated Host. The local bishop called it a divine sign in 2013, but his successor reopened the case, and it remains unresolved.

What happened

On October 21, 2006, the parish of San Martín de Tours (St. Martin of Tours) in Tixtla was holding a retreat. Tixtla is a town in the Mexican state of Guerrero, about ten miles east of the state capital, Chilpancingo. During Mass, a religious sister who was helping to distribute Holy Communion said she saw a reddish substance like blood coming from a consecrated Host. The priests set the Host aside and informed the bishop of Chilpancingo–Chilapa, Alejo Zavala Castro. He convened a theological commission to consider whether the event could be a hoax.

Unlike the cases in Buenos Aires, Sokółka, and Legnica, this report did not begin with a dropped Host left to dissolve in water. The sister said she saw the change happen during Communion.

What was examined

Scientific work began about three years later. In October 2009 the bishop invited Ricardo Castañón Gómez, the Bolivian researcher who had led the Buenos Aires investigation, to organize tests. His team finished in October 2012, and its conclusions were presented at a symposium organized by the diocese in May 2013.

As summarized by the investigators and by sympathetic Catholic outlets, the team reported:

  • that the red substance was blood containing human hemoglobin and human DNA, of blood type AB;
  • that two forensic studies using different methods showed the substance had come from inside the Host rather than being placed on its surface;
  • that the outer layer had clotted in 2006, while deeper layers still looked like fresh blood in February 2010;
  • that it contained intact red and white blood cells, and tissue they identified as heart muscle.

These findings were never published in a peer-reviewed journal, and only summaries are public. In 2024, the Catholic immunologist Kelly Kearse and his colleague Frank Ligaj examined those summaries. They noted that almost no detail was given about the hemoglobin test beyond its result, and that such tests can give false positives with contaminated material unless they are run alongside control wafers. By the investigators’ own account, the sample tested positive for a red-blood-cell marker but negative for two standard muscle markers, desmin and myosin, an odd result for heart tissue. The investigators also reported seeing plant cells here and there in the background.

In a separate 2024 paper, Kearse pointed out that bacteria can carry the same A and B antigens that blood tests detect, so an AB result on a contaminated sample does not show human blood. Accounts also disagree about the DNA. Promoters describe human DNA too degraded to profile, while Stacy Trasancos, summarizing Kearse’s work, writes that no human DNA was detected.

What the Church has said

On October 12, 2013, Bishop Zavala Castro issued a pastoral letter concluding that the events were supernatural. In Catholic News Agency’s translation, he called them “a divine sign” and “a true miracle.”

That was not the last word. Bishop Salvador Rangel Mendoza, appointed to the diocese in 2015, opened a new investigation and consulted the Vatican. In February 2022, days after his retirement, Rangel told ACI Prensa that Rome had called the case a Eucharistic phenomenon, that the investigations he ordered had not yet reported, and that the diocesan process was therefore unfinished. “Here they kind of went ahead to declare a miracle, but officially the pope has to declare it,” he said, in Catholic News Agency’s translation.

Since May 2024, the Vatican’s new norms govern cases like this. A bishop is to refrain from public statements in favor of a phenomenon’s supernatural character, his final judgment must be approved by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, and as a rule no one declares a phenomenon supernatural at all. A letter like the one issued in 2013 would not be issued under those rules. We have found no public statement on Tixtla since 2022.

Questions that remain

An unfinished process. By the account of the diocese’s own later bishop, the investigation is not complete. The 2013 letter is best read as one bishop’s judgment, which his successor chose to reexamine.

What has been published. The underlying laboratory reports have not been released in full or reviewed by independent scientists, so outsiders cannot check how the tests were done or what controls were used.

Handling. The Host was handled by several people over the years it took to investigate. That matters for DNA results in particular, since small traces of human DNA are easily left by touch.

The AB link. Devotional writers often connect Tixtla’s AB result with similar results reported for Lanciano and the Shroud of Turin, as if they pointed to one person. Kearse argues that only genetic markers, not blood type, could show a common source, and that no such comparison has been done.

What believers point to. The event was reported during Mass, in front of others, rather than discovered after days in water. The investigators also say two separate studies showed the substance coming from within the Host. Both points deserve a hearing. Neither can be weighed properly until the full data are public.

Sources and further reading

This account is written in our own words from the sources above. If you know of a correction or a better source, please tell us.