What happened
According to a tradition long kept in Lanciano, a town in the Abruzzo region of Italy, a priest-monk was saying Mass there sometime in the eighth century. He is usually described as a Basilian, a monk of the Greek tradition, and his name has not survived. The story says he had been troubled by doubts that Christ is truly present in the consecrated Host. As he spoke the words of consecration, the Host in his hands became a thin round of flesh, and the wine in the chalice became blood, which later clotted into five small, irregular pellets.
The church where this is said to have happened stood on the site of today’s church of San Francesco. The relics passed from the monks who served it to later custodians, and eventually to the Franciscans, who are documented in Lanciano from the 13th century. Their church was begun around the middle of that century and rebuilt in 1737. Today the flesh and the blood are shown together there in an 18th-century reliquary of silver and glass.
What was examined
The first recorded inspection took place in 1574, under Archbishop Gaspare Rodríguez. A well-known story says the pellets were weighed then, and that each one weighed as much as all five together. That claim appears only on an inscription set up in 1636, and later weighings did not confirm it.
The only scientific study came in 1970–71. With Vatican authorization, the Franciscans asked Odoardo Linoli, a pathologist who headed the hospital laboratory in Arezzo, to take and examine samples. He consulted Ruggero Bertelli, an anatomist at the University of Siena. Linoli presented his results in Lanciano on March 4, 1971, and published them that year in the Italian journal Quaderni Sclavo di Diagnostica. He reported that the flesh was human heart muscle, that the blood was human, that both were of blood group AB, and that he found no trace of preservatives.
What the Church has said
The Church has allowed and encouraged devotion at Lanciano for centuries, and the 1970–71 study was done with the Vatican’s permission. In a 2004 letter to the archbishop of Lanciano-Ortona, Pope John Paul II recalled visiting the relics while he was cardinal of Kraków, and spoke of “the famous miracle that dates back to the eighth century.”
Many popular sources say the Church has formally declared Lanciano a miracle, but we have not found such a decree. As with every event of this kind, Catholics are free to accept it or not.
Questions that remain
The late record. The earliest written references date from the 16th century, roughly 800 years after the date tradition gives. The Italian skeptic Silvano Fuso has stressed that no older source survives. The skeptical investigator Joe Nickell has also noted that several medieval miracle stories share the plot of a doubting priest, which may point to borrowing between traditions.
One investigator. Linoli took the samples, prepared them, and analyzed them himself, without an independent panel. The biologist Antonio Casolari has pointed out that Bertelli was consulted only at the end and saw neither the sampling nor the preparation of the slides.
The methods. In a 2024 peer-reviewed paper, two Catholic scientists, Kelly Kearse and Frank Ligaj, note that Linoli himself recorded fungal growth on the samples, that two of his chemical tests for hemoglobin came back negative, and that AB typing of old material is unreliable because some bacteria carry the same markers. They call for modern genetic testing with proper controls.
The age. The relics have never been radiocarbon-dated. The chemist Luigi Garlaschelli has argued that dating is needed to show whether the material really comes from the eighth century, and that natural mummification in a closed reliquary could account for its long survival.
The WHO story. Many accounts, including the 2005 ZENIT article about Linoli, say a World Health Organization commission confirmed his findings in the 1970s. Kearse and his colleagues found that neither the WHO nor the United Nations had any record of such a study. The cardiologist Franco Serafini, who tracked down the supposed report in Lanciano, called it a fraud: a front and back page about Lanciano attached to hundreds of unrelated pages on Egyptian mummies.
A believer can fairly answer that missing documents do not prove an event did not happen, and Linoli’s identification of heart tissue has not been disproved. Still, on present evidence the case rests on a local tradition first written down centuries later and on one contested study.
Visiting today
The relics are displayed in the Church of San Francesco, now the Sanctuary of the Eucharistic Miracle, in the center of Lanciano. The Conventual Franciscans care for the shrine, which reports about 500,000 visitors during the 2025 Jubilee year. Check the sanctuary’s website for hours before you go.
Sources and further reading
- Scientific Analysis of Eucharistic Miracles: Importance of a Standardization in Evaluation — Kelly Kearse and Frank Ligaj, Journal of Forensic Science and Research, November 2024. A peer-reviewed critique by Catholic scientists of Linoli's methods and of the WHO claim.
- Physician Tells of Eucharistic Miracle of Lanciano — ZENIT, May 5, 2005, via EWTN. Linoli's own account of his findings. The article's claim of a WHO study is unfounded.
- Letter of John Paul II to Archbishop Carlo Ghidelli of Lanciano-Ortona — October 4, 2004. The Pope recalls visiting the relics as cardinal of Kraków.
- Chiesa e Convento di San Francesco - Miracolo Eucaristico — Italian Ministry of Culture (Italian). The church's history and the tradition in brief.
- Eucharistic miracle of Lanciano — Wikipedia. A useful overview with references to the critical literature (Fuso, Garlaschelli, Casolari, Serafini). Its statement that the Church officially recognizes the miracle rests on a newspaper report.
This account is written in our own words from the sources above. If you know of a correction or a better source, please tell us.