I'm skeptical · Part 5

People who looked closely

Belief in the Real Presence has never been only for the credulous. Here are four people who looked at it seriously, from a pagan philosopher to an atheist phenomenologist, and what they concluded.

The apostle Thomas has become the patron saint of skeptics, and fairly so. When the other disciples told him they had seen the risen Jesus, he answered: “Unless I see in his hands the print of the nails, put my finger into the print of the nails, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe” (John 20:25). He wasn’t scolded for asking. He was met.

Here are four people who, from very different starting points, looked hard at the Christian claim and at the Eucharist. Their stories prove nothing on their own; thoughtful people have looked just as hard and concluded otherwise. But they show that believing this is not the same as never having thought about it.

Justin Martyr: the philosopher who shopped around

Justin was born around AD 100 in Flavia Neapolis (modern Nablus) to a pagan family, and set out to find the truth through philosophy. In his Dialogue with Trypho he describes the search with some humor: a Stoic who taught him nothing about God, a Peripatetic who wanted his fee settled first, a Pythagorean who sent him away for not knowing geometry, and the Platonists, who thrilled him for a while.

Two things changed his mind. One was a long conversation with an old man he met near the sea, who pointed him to the Hebrew prophets and to Christ. The other was watching how Christians died. “When I was delighting in the doctrines of Plato,” he wrote, “and heard the Christians slandered, and saw them fearless of death,” he came to see “that it was impossible that they could be living in wickedness and pleasure” (Second Apology, 12).

In Rome, around 155, he wrote the description of the Eucharist quoted in chapter 3, and closed that defense with an invitation any skeptic can respect:

And if these things seem to you to be reasonable and true, honour them; but if they seem nonsensical, despise them as nonsense…

Justin Martyr, First Apology, 68 (trans. Dods and Reith, 1885)

Around 165, he was executed in Rome for refusing to give up his faith.

John Henry Newman: the scholar who did the history

Newman (1801–1890) was one of Oxford’s most brilliant minds and a leading priest of the Church of England. Never a skeptic about God, he was deeply suspicious of Rome, and for years argued that the Church of England, not Rome, had kept faith with the early Church. The more he studied the early Church, the harder that position became to hold. In 1845 he became a Catholic, at the cost of his Oxford position and many friendships. He was canonized in 2019.

In his Apologia pro Vita Sua (1864), he addressed transubstantiation directly:

People say that the doctrine of Transubstantiation is difficult to believe; I did not believe the doctrine till I was a Catholic. I had no difficulty in believing it, as soon as I believed that the Catholic Roman Church was the oracle of God, and that she had declared this doctrine to be part of the original revelation. It is difficult, impossible, to imagine, I grant;—but how is it difficult to believe?

John Henry Newman, Apologia pro Vita Sua (1864)

The distinction matters. To imagine something is to picture how it works; to believe it is to accept it as true on good grounds. We believe plenty we can’t picture. Try picturing curved spacetime.

Edith Stein: the atheist philosopher

Edith Stein was born in 1891 in Breslau (now Wrocław, Poland), the youngest child in a devout Jewish family. As a teenager, by her own account, she deliberately gave up praying. She became a gifted philosopher, earning her doctorate in 1917 under Edmund Husserl, the founder of phenomenology, with a thesis on empathy.

Around the time of her doctorate, she saw a woman come into the empty Frankfurt Cathedral straight from the market, shopping basket in hand, and kneel for a short prayer. Stein had only seen people go to synagogues and churches for services; this woman seemed to have come for a private conversation. Stein never forgot it. (Catholics would add that the church wasn’t really empty: the Blessed Sacrament reserved there is why such visits make sense.)

Then, in the summer of 1921, staying with a friend, she picked up the autobiography of St. Teresa of Ávila and read it through the night. When she finished, she said to herself: “This is the truth.”

She was baptized on January 1, 1922. Looking back, she wrote: “My longing for truth was a single prayer.” In 1933, barred from teaching by the Nazi racial laws, she entered the Carmelite convent in Cologne and took the name Teresa Benedicta of the Cross. In 1942 she was arrested in the Netherlands and deported to Auschwitz, where she was murdered, probably on August 9. She was canonized in 1998.

André Frossard: the communist leader’s son

André Frossard (1915–1995) grew up in a home so thoroughly unbelieving that the question of God simply didn’t come up. His father was the first general secretary of the French Communist Party.

On July 8, 1935, aged twenty, he walked into a chapel on the rue d’Ulm in Paris, run by nuns devoted to adoration, looking for a friend. At the far end of the chapel, the Blessed Sacrament was exposed for adoration. He later wrote that he didn’t know what it was. Within a few minutes, by his own account, he walked out a believer.

He later survived Gestapo imprisonment as a member of the Resistance, became a well-known journalist, and was elected to the Académie française. In 1969 he told the story in a bestseller, Dieu existe, je l’ai rencontré (“God exists, I have met him”).

A skeptic will rightly say that a sudden experience proves nothing about its cause. What stands out is where it happened: not at a sermon or a rally, but in silence, before the Host.

What these stories do and don’t show

None of these four was short on intelligence, or on reasons to resist. They came by very different roads: argument and the courage of martyrs, the history of the early Church, close attention to experience, an encounter in silence. Each came to believe that what lies on the altar is Christ.

That doesn’t make them right. What it shows is that this question is open to serious minds, and that for some of them, the turning point came less from an argument about the Eucharist than from meeting the One it is said to be.

Going further

Scripture quotations are from the World English Bible (public domain) unless otherwise noted. References marked “CCC” are to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.